The Lititz Hoagie Shop Owner Who Bought a Second Bruno’s

Some people buy an extra sandwich. Jessica Butzer bought an extra sandwich shop.

Butzer, a Lititz resident, became the owner of Bruno’s of Lititz in March 2020. She later completed the purchase of a second Bruno’s, at the Shoppes at Greenfield off Route 30 in Lancaster, giving her two locations of a hoagie shop that Lancaster and Susquehanna Valley customers have regularly ranked among the best in the region.

Buying a restaurant days before a shutdown

The timing of the first purchase could hardly have been more difficult. Butzer took over the Lititz shop in March 2020, the same month Pennsylvania ordered non-essential businesses closed and restaurants limited to takeout and delivery to slow the spread of COVID-19.

Bruno’s adapted by leaning on what hoagie shops do well: food that travels. In mid-March 2020, staff were carrying trays of Italian, turkey, roast beef and ham hoagies out to local businesses that wanted to feed their own employees. The shop offered pickup, takeout and catering, including individually wrapped hoagies for workplaces trying to limit shared food. Soups rounded out the menu.

That catering business helped keep the shop busy through the hardest months of the pandemic. Bruno’s later reopened to walk-in customers.

Growing from one shop to two

In September 2021, Bruno’s of Lititz added a food truck, extending its reach to events and locations beyond its storefront. The second shop followed: the Bruno’s at 555 Greenfield Road in Lancaster, near the Costco shopping area, a busy commercial corridor with heavy lunchtime traffic from nearby offices.

Butzer also owns Renewal Kombucha in Lititz, a fermented tea business, making her one of a number of local entrepreneurs who run more than one small food business in town.

Where to find it

Bruno’s of Lititz has been located at 11 Kleine Lane, above Greco’s Ice Cream and just north of the Wilbur Chocolate retail store on North Broad Street. The location puts it in the middle of one of the busiest walking stretches of downtown, near the hotel and apartments built on the former Wilbur factory site.

Hours and menus can change, so check the shop’s current listings before you go, particularly for the food truck schedule.

What makes a hoagie a hoagie

In Pennsylvania, few food arguments get more heated than the hoagie. The name is most closely tied to Philadelphia, which declared the hoagie its official sandwich in 1992, and the style spread west across the state. A proper hoagie starts with a long, crusty roll, soft inside, and is built with cold cuts and cheese, then topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, oil and seasonings. The Italian, with layers of cured meats and provolone, is the classic.

Lancaster County hoagie shops have their own followings, and tray orders for parties, graduations and office lunches are a big part of the business. For many shops, catering is what carries them through slow weekday afternoons.

Small business ownership in Lititz

Butzer’s path reflects a pattern seen across downtown Lititz. Many of the borough’s shops and restaurants are owner-operated, and owners often grow by adding a second location, a food truck, or a separate business that shares customers with the first. The approach spreads risk, but it also demands long hours, especially in the food business, where margins are thin and staffing is a constant challenge.

The pandemic tested that model. Owners who could shift quickly to takeout, catering and delivery had the best chance of getting through, and many Lititz restaurants are still operating today because they did.

Do you know a Lititz business owner with a story worth telling? Suggest a profile through our Contact page. Find more local profiles in People & Profiles.

Related coverage